JanitorAI's mandatory ID verification and DeepSeek proxy outages pushed a lot of regulars out the door in late 2025. We tested every realistic alternative — here's what's worth your time.
A late-2025 policy update changed the platform meaningfully. These are the three reasons we kept hearing in our research.
Late-2025 update requires document submission to access NSFW. Most users won't upload a government ID to a chatbot site, so they migrated.
Chats break repeatedly when the free DeepSeek route fails. Bring-your-own-API-key works but raises monthly cost above what most paid alternatives charge.
Janitor relies on third-party APIs you have to configure yourself. Newer alternatives ship working models out of the box — zero setup.
All six platforms compared on the things that matter.
| CrushOn AI | Candy.AI | DreamGF | Joyland | SpicyChat | Replika | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Starting price | $5.99/mo | $12.99/mo | $9.99/mo | $9.99/mo | Free | $19.99/mo |
| Unfiltered NSFW | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | Paid only | ✓ | Limited |
| No ID required | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| Real free tier | ✓ | Preview only | Trial | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| Native image gen | OK | ✓ Best | ✓ Best | OK | Weak | No |
| Voice chat | No | ✓ | No | No | No | ✓ |
| Character library | 100k+ | Curated | Curated | 60k+ | 100k+ | 1 (yours) |
| Best for | Janitor refugees | Image-first RP | Visual scenes | Anime / story | Free users | Companion (not RP) |
From $5.99/mo · Generous free tier · No ID
The closest spiritual successor to JanitorAI's "active community + uncensored characters" feel. Largest user-created character library outside Character.AI, fully unfiltered NSFW, and the free tier is genuinely usable for daily chats — not a 5-message tease. Cheapest paid plan in the category by a meaningful margin. If you're unsure where to migrate, start here.
From $12.99/mo · No ID
The most polished AI companion product on the market. Strong native image generation built into chat, voice messages with cloned voices, and the conversational model holds character better than most. Heavy production value compared to the open-source-feeling alternatives. If image quality matters more than character variety, this is the pick.
From $9.99/mo · No ID
Image-heavy roleplay focus. If your main use of Janitor was the image-attached scenes, DreamGF leans further in that direction. Less text-roleplay depth than CrushOn but stronger on the visual side. Tight integration of generated images with the chat narrative.
From $9.99/mo · Free tier · No ID
If you came to Janitor for long-form storytelling and anime characters, Joyland is the closest fit. 60,000+ user-created anime characters, deep memory, and adjustable content settings from family-friendly all the way to fully unrestricted. NSFW is gated behind paid plan.
Free with token system · No ID
Closest one-to-one replacement if you used JanitorAI's free tier. Token-based system, large character library, fully unfiltered. Zero friction to try. Most "drop-in" of all the alternatives — the UI feels familiar to ex-Janitor users almost immediately.
From $19.99/mo · No ID
Different category — Replika is for long-term emotional companion relationships, not character roleplay. NSFW is limited and the focus is consistent personality over time. Listed because some former Janitor users were really there for connection, not the spicy stuff. If that's you, it's worth the price.
If you're migrating now and don't want to overthink it, start with CrushOn AI for the best free tier and largest unfiltered character library. Pay the $5.99 if you want everything. Use Candy.AI if image generation matters more than character variety. Try Joyland for anime or long storytelling. Skip Replika unless your Janitor use was actually emotional companionship rather than roleplay. SpicyChat is the right call if you never paid for Janitor anyway and want a free drop-in.
Late-2025 policy change tied to NSFW content compliance and payment processor requirements. The platform is technically still free but the verified-NSFW gate caused a real exodus in early 2026.
Mixed. CrushOn was flagged by Mozilla for privacy concerns in 2026 — read their privacy policy if that matters to you. Candy.AI and Joyland have the cleanest privacy posture among the picks above. None of them sell character data to advertisers as far as we've found, but assume chat content is logged for moderation/training.
Not via export — JanitorAI doesn't offer a clean export. You can copy character cards manually (description, personality, scenario) into CrushOn or SpicyChat, both of which use a similar character-card format.
SpicyChat and CrushOn. Joyland has a noticeably different UX focused on storytelling.
Four weeks of daily use across all six platforms, including character creation, long-context conversation tests, image generation comparisons, and pricing tier evaluation. Scores are weighted across content quality, feature depth, value for money, and migration friction from Janitor.
No. We're an independent comparison site. We use the JanitorAI name in a nominative-fair-use capacity to compare products. JanitorAI™ and all other product names belong to their respective owners.